Top Menu

Best Crib Mattress 2016: Reviews and Recommendation

best crib mattress Best Crib Mattress

Are you the one who keeps their children above everything? The one who Intends to keep the whole world aside and your precious child the other?

I’m sure your answer is yes, otherwise you would not have come here and stuck around. So, warm greetings and let’s move forward together.

The thought of buying a nice crib mattress come first, whenever you try to make your baby boy or girl’s room into a fabulous theme park. And I can assist you in this regard. At first a quick overview of myself. I am a single mom of three. Successfully parenting them for years and have helped many with parenting. I am more than sure to do the same with you. I am an expert of different crib mattresses and I point out the best crib mattress out of them.

The 4 Best Crib Mattress Comparison Table

Product NameTypeDimensions (Inches)Weight (Pounds)PriceOur Rating
Newton Crib Mattress Lightweight Wovenaire28 x 5.5 x 5211$$$
Naturepedic Quilted Organic Cotton DeluxeOrganic52 x 27.8 x 650$$
Colgate EcoSpring Ultra IIInnerspring51.6 x 27.2 x 622$$
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Foam51.6 x 27.2 x 58.3$

Welcome, sweet moms and pops. It’s great to know that you care more about your infant child. Your love is not ordinary and you have enhanced your boundary of caring by giving a keen look to the surroundings of your child as well. You may be wondering by now, that

who does not? Who do not love their child?
You are right, there is none, but not everybody loves their children effectively. You love your sweet little cutie pie a lot but does not notice the discomfort of your child, then your love is pointless. It may sound rude, but seriously, your daughter/son does not need this kind of love. Only love won’t make your child feel comfortable or make him/her healthy but the choice of the crib mattress will do. And that is what I am talking about so far, beyond ordinary love.

You have shown the sign of beneficent love for your child coming here, and that is great! Let’s proceed to different crib mattress reviews

You may not have noticed yet; an infant child sleeps up to 18 hours a day. It is recommended to buy the best crib mattress for your baby where he/she spends most of the time. The best crib mattress should be firm. A soft crib mattress may take the shape of your baby’s face resulting choking and discomfort of your baby.

In a HURRY! For quick peak over best crib mattress recommendation. Jump here

How you will choose the best crib mattress

To ensure the purchase of the best crib mattress, you should possess a clear view of the types of a crib mattress.

According to composing procedure, there are two

  • Foam crib mattress
    These mattresses are made of polyurethane or foams as we know them. This is coated by a cover usually made of fabric or vinyl.
  • Innerspring crib mattress
    These mattresses are made of springs equipped with several layers of it. On top of it, there is a coating of a cover.  There are border rods that go around from top to bottom. Some spring crib mattresses lack this and I strongly recommend not to buy them.
According to ingredients, there are two
  • Organic or eco-friendly crib mattress
    Organic or eco-friendly crib mattresses are made of eco-friendly organic ingredients. Completely organic crib mattress Is usually a little bit pricey. There are some organic options with a very little percentage of chemicals, PVC or plastics. They cost less but does not ensure total organic protection for your baby.
  • Conventional crib mattress
    All of the ingredients are made industrially. These are made with the fact that they are made for the newborn babies are kept in mind. So they are not excessively toxically exposed. But when it comes to your baby, I think there is no safe level of exposure. If this is a top concern of yours, you should buy an organic crib mattress.
If you get confused on which type will suit best for your baby, it is described below.

There is a prejudice that innerspring crib mattresses are better than foam crib mattresses. It may be the truth for former times but the technology has traveled a long successful path as now and the situation has  been altered.

How? The Foam crib mattresses out-standards the spring ones. And foam crib mattresses are lighter than the spring crib mattresses. It lacks the optimal longevity so far, but that is not a problem now anymore.
According to director of marketing of Colgate Juvenile Products, Dennis Schuetz, “A top-quality foam crib mattress will hold up just as long as an innerspring crib mattress with normal use,”

But consider that Foam crib mattresses can be below average quality too. You should look for denser inner foam while buying foam crib mattress. The denser the better. It helps the mattress to secure a firm whereabouts. Innerspring crib mattress can also be premium quality and they are good also. If the spring crib mattresses are the one you personally prefer, I won’t argue with you to change your mind. All I have to say is go for the one with better gauge steels. Best gauge steels lead to the best crib mattress.

Best Crib Mattress: Reviews & Recommendation

At first, I apologize for the life stories you may find while going ahead. Actually, I cannot but resist it.

Here is a list of the best crib mattress for their own kind according to my view.I used the first one for my first son, Ricky and the second for my Micky. I personally experienced all of them within my neighborhood. You can try these for your baby without any doubt about safety as I researched on behalf of you. It is safe to buy them. But if something happens during shipping or maybe you are not satisfied enough with the product after the arrival of your baby’s crib mattress, you can always return the product and get a new one. You may jump to the section through (here) to know what I kept in mind selecting these and how I choose the best crib mattress.

Here you will find the best crib mattress of each crib mattress category

Best Crib Mattress – Lightweight Wovenaire 

Newton Crib Mattress Review
Newton Crib Mattress Review

I used it for my Ricky. Wow, wasn’t I happy then! Anyway, I chose this over others. I was searching for a safe and durable crib mattress for Ricky, as soon as I returned home from the hospital and well enough to barely move around here and there. At first, I hit online and got to know about newton. It kept shouting about this wovenaire and how safe it is for a baby. I always hate weird marketing and thought it as the same sort of thing.

That’s why I decided to dig dip, I found that this Wovenaire is some sort of cushioning that is made of food grade polymer. It is well built, it is light. And it is best for holding air. It can hold 90% air of its own volume! In the meantime, I was well aware of the necessity of air circulation in crib mattresses.

So I hit a store closest to mine and fortunately found one. I tried to uphold it and it was lifted quite frankly. I personally felt that wovenaire and it was really impressive. Very lite and when I pressed it hard to the center, I felt an emission of air actively. I slightly heard it too. I felt It was a great product for me. Then I purchased it. Later on, I found some of more extra features of newton crib mattress official website. Which are mentioned in below-

  • Washing Convenience: In my opinion, it is the best part of this crib mattress. It’s completely washable, with the least effort.  Since it is a crib mattress, the importance of hygiene comes at the very first.  As you just cannot throw it into a washing machine, it is a strenuous job to completely clean a crib mattress of seen smudges and unseen bacteria. It is very light and absorbs water itself making the whole thing very easy. An easy and artistic walk to remember.
  • Breathe-Through: It is claimed by newton that it is 100% breathable. It seems pointless to me. You can’t measure somethings breath-ability like that. You can tell is it breathable or not, but cannot give percentage out of it accurately. It gave my baby comfort and he could breathe while sleeping downward. That I can assure.
  • Very Lightweight And Airy: It is made with very light material and holds lots of air. That stops the possibility of overheating preventing sweaty backs.
  • The Wovenaire: The wovenaire comes here again. It is really a handy material. The safe food-grade polymer that is easy to wash. A marvelous choice for a crib mattress. Newton research team should be appreciated for this innovation. They have done a great job finding this piece of tech and modifying it for crib mattresses. It secures the cleanest and the most toxic free environment for a baby. It contains very little core ingredients of its main volume. And the little the main volume is the little chance of exposure to the bacteria. So spacious for air, confirms the most comfort maintaining the crucial level of firmness a crib mattress should.

Best Crib Mattress – Organic 

Naturepedic Quilted Organic Cotton Deluxe Crib Mattress Review
Naturepedic Quilted Organic Cotton Deluxe Crib Mattress Review

Life went on. In the meantime, I gave birth of my second child. A baby girl illuminated my sweet home. Her name is Micky. Anyway, I was so into the crib mattresses then but what did I do with two mattresses. After Micky was born, I got the opportunity to buy another one, that time I went to the organic crib mattresses. I heard so much about organic crib mattresses and was wanting to buy one for long. Everything was smooth then and I wouldn’t mind paying little extra for the mattress where my precious mickey would sleep.This time, I wanted to ensure comfort for my baby, while the firmness is in the safe zone. That is why I went for the naturepedics.

Basically organic crib mattresses are made from organic components. But certain parts are not always organic. That means the covers or some other parts are not organic. It does not make any sense that you buy an organic crib mattress for ensuring best safety precaution possible for your baby but the portions with what your baby will actively interact, like the cover is not organic. So I did plenty of crib mattress review possible and chose this one. It looked like the all in one organic crib mattress with no chemical emitting components. Naturepedic Quilted Organic Cotton Deluxe Crib Mattress seemed 1 hundred percent organic to with no harmful chemical or toxin. This Naturepedic’s top notch product where naturepedic authority put their top most effort making the whole crib mattress a piece of art.

How? See below

  • Cotton Fitting: The very first benefit of an organic crib mattress is organic cotton fitting. Naturepedic Quilted Organic Cotton Deluxe Crib Mattress contains 100% organic cotton. It gives the most chemical free possible sleeping environment for your baby. Things to know about organic cotton is it is completely natural. It is grown without different chemical fertilizer or other harmful elements like synthetic pesticides or herbicides.
  • Waterproof Organic Cotton Cover on The Infant Part: Usually, the portion where other organic crib mattresses lack the feature “Organic” is the cover of the mattress itself. A mattress filled with organic foam but wrapped up with normal conventional toxic cover makes no sense. Normally organic crib mattresses cost more cause the organic ingredients are costly. Manufacturers try to round up this cost by reducing the manufacturing cost of cover, edge binding, fabrics etc. But as I said, it makes no sense to buy a semi-organic crib mattress with relatively more expenditure as it makes no excessive benefit. if you want organic protection for your baby then you should go for the maximum.
    Naturepedic brings this crib mattress with a waterproof organic cotton cover on the infant part. It makes great sense to provide waterproof feature while your baby is still an infant. Naturepedic authority publicly confirms that no inorganic material is used to make the infant side cover waterproof.
  • Best Treat Possible For Toddlers: Well, the toddler part is another history. This crib mattress featured with a luxuriously quilted cotton fabric. Very perfect for the toddler and older children. Very comfortable. But it is recommended not to put an infant child here. Be patient and only flip the mattress when you are completely sure that your child will be safe there.I repeat, flip the mattress only then when you are completely sure that it is safe for your baby.This part is not waterproof. But it is made for toddler children so that is not a matter here. Actually, the covers that do not let the water go inside is likely to contain toxic material. As I say always, you should use waterproof organic protector pad instead.
  • Comfort and Durability: This crib mattress is a hybrid crib mattress. That means Naturepedic made this crib mattress with a great combination of spring and foam. No other organic crib mattress provides this type of facility. Naturepedic Quilted Organic Cotton Deluxe Crib Mattress uses a spring system that prevents the mattress from further sagging. It is featured with 252 coils of innerspring aided with robust 9-gauge edge support. It is the perfect example for necessary firmness with ultimate comfort for your baby, with durability.
You may find some negative opinion, that’s because of wrong alteration time. You have to make sure that you are flipping over the mattress after being completely sure that your baby has become a toddler and it is completely safe for him/her. The quilted part of this mattress is too comfortable for an infant child and it is dangerous. whenever the whole pressure will be upon a tiny certain part, it is likely to fall.

Best Crib Mattress – Innerspring

Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II Review
Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II Review

The Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II is also a hybrid crib mattress that comes with strong durable innersprings. I am not a fan of all in one spring based crib mattresses. I rather prefer hybrid mattresses. This mattress made with natural and sustainable materials. It is a little bit overweight comparing the above. That is for the innersprings. But it ensures longevity.

Why Buy Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II?

  • Extra firm: The Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II provides extra firmness. This mattress is filled with a reliable 150 thick 135-gauge steel coils, which is great for innerspring crib mattresses. The necessary firmness for your baby with the guarantee of a long durable life. The spring will not turn into a ramshackle one overtime.
  • Great Lifetime: This crib mattress is a giant regarding lifetime. Apart from the thick durable innerspring, it has also a much stronger Edge support from 90-gauge steel border rods. You should check my innerspring crib mattress buying guide to find the importance of border rod. You will find why border rods play an important role to make the best crib mattress.
  • Organic Cotton Cover: The cotton that covers the Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II is organic. This is the best crib mattress where the implementation of organic material is done perfectly. The usage of organic cotton in cover makes great sense. Here’s notable that cotton is a very good choice for cover as it helps the mattress to pass the flammability test ensuring no toxic coating. And whenever the cotton is organic itself, it is great.
  • Extra Comfort With Allergens Free Environment: The natural cotton batting layers secure extra comfort for your baby while keeping the firmness level in a safe zone. It also confirms optimal protection from allergens.

Best Crib Mattress – Foam

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress Review
Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress Review

Let me introduce you with the Sealy Corp. at your service. Sealy Corp. is a renown crib mattress manufacturer that ensures the best combination possible of price to performance ratio. They have been making marvelous foam crib mattresses a while. This feature confirmed that if you want to buy not only the best foam crib mattress out there, but also within a compact budget, you have to go to Sealy foam crib mattresses.

They have been doing some amazing work putting natural soybean oil into foam manufacturing and that effectively reduces the toxicity of the normal conventional foam.

The foam crib mattress I am going to declare as the best crib mattress choice of myself is the Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress.

Find out why

  • Soybean Oil Based Foam: Actually, Foams are made from Polyurethane (PUR and PU) and some other adhesives. Usually, they are extremely toxic for your baby. But the foam used in Sealy soybean foam-core crib mattress is soybean oil based. Soybean oil is capable of altering those toxic materials. It is the main feature of these crib mattress. It is cheap, it is durable, it is non-toxic. Great convenience. Here in this sector, it outruns all the other.
  • Waterproof With Safety: This crib mattress is waterproof. I am not a fan of waterproof feature but that is only because whatever is used to make the mattress waterproof, usually contains toxic material. If there is any way to bypass this demerit, the waterproof feature is great. It makes the mattress impervious to water. That prevents allergens. Sealy uses GREENGUARD certified embossed reinforced vinyl laminate cover that is free of any harmful lead and phthalates, to make the cover waterproof.This feature makes this foam mattress the best crib mattress of its kind!!You may be wondering what about the air circulation if its waterproof. It has several big side ventilation pockets that ensure the proper air ventilation.
  • Lightweight: It is very lightweight. Easy to move, Easy to handle. Need no extra effort to move.

What Kept In Mind To Choose the Best Crib Mattress

  • Foam density: A best foam crib mattress will be filled with much denser foam. The denser the foam is, the more it will keep its self-form and will not take your baby’s shape as they spend a lot of time on it. So, the density of the foam is a big deal.
  • Cover quality: Usually, a foam crib mattress is covered with fabric or vinyl cover. Crib mattresses covered with the cheap material will tear within short days thus making your purchasing an unsuccessful one. Cover plays big role cause it is the main portion that may expose your baby to toxicity. So cover ingredient is very important.
  • Air circulation: A best crib mattress will circulate air Properly.It ensures the longevity of a crib mattress and makes allergen-free.
  • Spring layers: It is an important aspect to look out whenever buying an innerspring crib mattress. The more the spring layers, the better the crib mattress is. The temperament of the springs matters as well.
  • Coil count and steel thickness: Coil count indicates the number of the spring coils. some expensive crib mattresses also show the number of coil counts over 300. Actually, it is not necessary to have more than 150-200. The spring mattresses filled with 150 coils but with thicker steel can be firmer than the one filled with 250 coils but of wicked quality.
  • Border rods: Border rods are another very important aspect of an innerspring crib mattress that holds the whole mattress in shape.
  • Insulator pad: A well-concentrated layer of insulator exists on top of the spring coils. Best insulator pad is usually made with shredded coconut shells. Another pad named ‘rag’ is also available in the market wrapping spring crib mattresses.
  • Cushion: Cushions are usually made from foam, polyester or cotton. Cotton is the best cushion solution as it is the best safe solution to pass the flammability test.

Didn’t Quite Get There?

Well, that’s all for the moment. The things mentioned above may seem all blabbering to you. To get a better and clearer picture of what matters to make a crib mattress the best crib mattress, visit here for a detailed crib mattress buying guide. There You can find the necessary info on the checking system of these qualities too.
May your child be in good health. Happy parenting!!

If you managed to fit into the baby crib somehow, You will feel comfortable too. ha ha ha.