Best Crib Mattress 2017: Reviews and Recommendations

what's the best cot bed mattress to buyBest Mattress For A Crib

Which is the best crib mattress for a baby to choose? Obviously you know it’s going to be the one that’s the safest for your baby, but how on earth do you choose from all the different brand names…. Colgate, Sealy, Simmons,Naturpedic-there are lot of brand names to choose from.

And once you get past the brand names, if you haven’t had a meltdown by now, then what filling do you choose? Synthetic, organic cotton, wool, coconut fibre, inner springs, how firm how, soft, should I buy a breathable mattress for infants and the list goes on!

The thought of buying the right crib mattress is important as that’s where your newest family member will be spending a lot of time! And you definitely want to be comfortable in knowing you’ve made the right choice.

How Do I Know Which Is The Best Crib Mattress For A Baby To Choose …

I know buying all of those gorgeous teeny tiny baby clothes is so much fun and it’s really hard to know when to stop isn’t it! And looking for those other important baby items such as strollers and car seats is pretty exciting too. There are so many different types of strollers to choose from and it all depends on where / how you will use one …

When I thought about choosing the right baby crib pad, my stomach clutched a bit in fear because there is so much information out there. It’s actually quite hard to know where to start. Just like every other item you buy for your baby or the nursery, a great deal of thought and care needs to go into purchasing a top rated crib mattress. And that, is where I hope I can help you as I’ve had to buy a few crib mattresses over the years.

Product NameTypeCustomer ReviewsMore Details

The Top Rated Crib Mattress: Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress

100% Breathable, Organic and Washable

4.7 / 5 Stars

209 Customer Reviews

More Details!
Click Here

Moonlight Slumber - Little Star Organic Crib Mattress

4.8 / 5 Stars

11 Customer Reviews

More Details!
Click Here

Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II - Organic Cotton Innerspring Crib Mattress with Waterproof Cover

4.8 / 5 Stars

16 Customer Reviews

More Details!
Click Here

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress - Hypoallergenic Soy Foam, Extra Firm, Durable Waterproof Cover, Certified Foam

4.3 /5 Stars

504 Customer Reviews

More Details!
Click Here

Who Am I?

First a quick overview of myself. We are a family of five, my husband Jeff, me, Claire, Hunter, Darcy and Daisy. Successfully parenting them over the years- a combination of experience, trial and sometimes error has helped us encourage 3 great kids to grow up and of whom we are very proud! I have become something of an expert in picking different crib mattresses, and many things baby, which are worth investing in, so, I’d like to share those insights with you….


The 4 Best Crib Mattresses For A Crib

You may not be aware a baby often sleeps anywhere up to 18 hours a day…. I highly recommend you buy the best crib mattress you can afford for your baby where he/she spends most of the time. The right mattress should be firm, not too soft and to fit snugly into the crib. There shouldn’t be any gaps between the mattress pad and actual crib. Not all mattresses are safe surprisingly so you need to be aware.

In a HURRY! Like to jump straight to reviews?

How Will You Choose The Best Crib Mattress?

To decide on the best crib mattress, you need to decide which type of crib mattress…. as there are 2 types

  • Foam crib mattress
    These mattresses are made of polyurethane or foams as we know them. This is covered by an outer shell usually made of fabric or vinyl. The outer covers can be waterproof or not and or removable. I strongly suggest removable so you can wash them. Babies poo and wee a lot!
  • Innerspring crib mattress
    These mattresses are made of steel springs covered with several layers of padding. The padding has a cover which can be waterproof, or not, and or removable . There are border rods that go around from top to bottom. Some innerspring crib mattresses lack this and I strongly recommend not to buy them.

Then there are materials the mattresses are made from. Today there are a wide range of choices thankfully. There are a range of accompanying prices to match. You can spend from $50 to over $1000…. or more in some cases.

  • Organic or eco-friendly crib mattress
    Organic or eco-friendly crib mattresses are made of eco-friendly organic ingredients such as cotton, coconut fiber or wool. Completely organic crib mattress’s can be a little more pricey. There are some organic options which include a very minimal percentage of chemicals, PVC or plastics. They cost less, but of course don’t give you total organic protection for your baby. There are many of affordable organic crib mattress options which don’t cost a fortune.
  • Conventional crib mattress
    All of the materials used are made from synthetics. These are generally cheaper, do not breath well and release noxious gasses over time. Considering the long hours your baby spends sleeping, they can be exposed to quite a few toxins. When it comes to your baby, I don’t believe there is a safe level of exposure with their soft skin. If this is a strong concern of yours, you should seriously look at buying an organic crib mattress. As you are deciding which design to buy, make sure you read all those crib mattress pad reviews. Actual user experience shared from parents is priceless.
  • Breathable Mattress pads for baby’s are well worth considering. Keeping your little ones sleeping areas as safe and healthy as possible is important. If your baby turns face down, they can breathe through the cover. As they can be sweaty little creatures, breathable mattress pads for baby’s help regulate body temperature.


There is something of an old fashioned prejudice that innerspring crib mattresses are better, safer, stronger than foam crib mattresses. Years ago this may well have been true, but technology has advanced considerably these days. I know you will have an open mind and look at numerous options before buying…

  • How? Foam crib mattresses can be just as durable and offer top quality models as an inner spring pad mattress. Foam crib mattresses are lighter and much easier to handle, especially if you turn the mattress frequently.
    According to director of marketing of Colgate Juvenile Products, Dennis Schuetz, “A top-quality foam crib mattress will hold up just as long as an innerspring crib mattress with normal use,”
  • But keep in mind foam crib mattresses for a baby can be below average quality too. Always look for a denser inner foam. The denser the better. The tighter cell structure helps the mattress to keep its shape and firmness. Innerspring crib mattress can also be premium quality and they are an excellent safe choice also. If you personally prefer innerspring crib mattresses, research your chosen mattress and read all the reviews- and that goes for any mattress. I will say go for the ones with better gauge steels.

Best Crib Mattress: Reviews & Recommendation

Here is a list of 4 of the best crib mattress which I feel offer safety, durability and longevity. Jeff and I have used them all. If something happens during shipping, or maybe you are not satisfied enough with the product after the arrival, you can always return the product and get a new one. You can jump to this section here to learn how and why I selected these brandsand how I choose the best crib mattress.

Here you will find the best crib mattresses for cribs reviews

The Best Crib Mattress For A Baby Is The Newton Lightweight Wovenaire

Newton Crib Mattress Review

I decided on the Newton Wovenaire Organic Mattress for Hunter, my first born. Wow, wasn’t I happy then! I chose this one over others as I wanted a natural, safe and durable crib mattress for Hunter. I had read about the issues with synthetic mattresses and off-gassing as babies sleep and how this affects their well being…..

I Began Researching….

As soon as I returned home from hospital, I began researching. Initially we had a crib which was passed down from my cousin and I very strongly felt we needed to buy a brand new one. At first, I jumped online and on doing some research, found the Newton. This particular non toxic crib mattress mentioned this feature called Wovenaire and how safe it is for a baby. I always hate weird marketing and thought it was the same sort of thing. It isn’t at all.

The Cushion / Comfort Factor Of The Wovenaire Is Awesome!

That’s why I decided to dig deeper. I found the Newton’s Wovenaire component is a type of cushioning made of 10% food grade polymer. It is well built and lightweight which makes it easier to turn and to clean. And, best of all, is the core of air. This is a breathable mattress for infants and can hold 90% air of its own volume! In the meantime, I was well aware of the necessity of air circulation in crib mattresses.

No Foam, No Latex, No Springs And A Washable Cover For Leaked Poo And Wee…

The Newton mattress for babies is wrapped in a breathable, three-dimensional fabric that provides comfort and unzips for easy washing. The standout feature which appealed most to me, the Newton contains no foam, latex, springs, glue, or allergens and is 100% recyclable.So I hit the closest baby store closest to our place and fortunately found one there. I tried lifting it up, as regularly turning crib mattresses is important and it was surprisingly light quite frankly. I was really impressed with its features.

As well as being lightweight for ease of handling, when I pressed down hard in the center, I felt the air actively move. I could just slightly hear the air movement. I felt the Newton was a great product for Hunter so I purchased it! Also, this model had some of the best crib mattress pad reviews from users who were really happy with its performance. Later on, I found some additional extra features of Newton Wovenaire crib mattress mentioned on the official website. Here they are:)

  • Hygiene: In my opinion, it’s the best part of this non toxic crib mattress. It’s completely washable, with the least effort. Since it is a crib mattress, the importance of hygiene is high. As you just can’t throw it in a washing machine, it’s a strenuous job to completely clean a crib mattress of unseen bacteria and leakage. The cover zips off and you throw it in the washing machine, dry it and a short time later baby has a clean fresh bed. The cover consists of two layers of highly breathable spacer fabric which are quilted together in a cloud pattern to create soft pillows of air.
  • Breathable: Newton claims this pad is 100% breathable which is a bit of a puzzle to me…. How do you measure a % of breath-ability like that? You can tell if is it breathable or not, but can you really give an accurate percentage? I do know Hunter was comfortable and he could safely breathe when he turned himself over and was sleeping downward. Newton says “In fact, Independent testing shows that babies can breathe right through it, greatly reducing the risk of suffocation.”
  • Very Lightweight And Airy: It is made with very light material and holds a lot of air. The temperature regulation prevents the possibility of overheating and sweaty backs, making it one of the top rated baby mattresses for breathability.
  • The Wovenaire: The Wovenaire is a brilliant design and possibly the best mattress for infants as it’s the only one of its kind. The safe, food-grade polymer is easy to wash. You can put it in the tub and rinse it off for the cleanest and least toxic environment for a baby.
best crib mattress to prevent sids

Best Organic Mattress For Baby Crib – The Little Star

Moonlight Slumber - Little Star Organic Crib Mattress

Life went on its busy way as it does… In the meantime, I gave birth to my second child, a gorgeous baby boy with big blue eyes we named Darcy. After Darcy was born, I decided to research into the benefits of choosing one of the best organic crib mattresses.

The Best Organic Crib Mattress Pad Is A Healthy Investment…

I thought perhaps buying one would be a good healthy investment. I wouldn’t mind paying little extra for the mattress. This time, I wanted to ensure comfort for my baby, while the firmness is in the safe zone. That is why I went for the Little Star Organic Crib Mattress. Plus this is a 2 stage crib mattress which will suit a toddlers bed. They grow so fast don’t they…

What Is An Organic Crib Mattress?

Basically organic mattresses for baby cribs are made from 100% or close to 100% organic components. However, some parts may not always be organic or certified. This simply means the cover or some part is not organic. It doesn’t make sense that you buy an organic crib mattress when parts of the mattress your baby actively interact are not organic. I like the Moonlight Slumber Mattress as it has ZERO Halogens, Tris, Nanoparticles, PVC, Vinyl, PBDE, PBB, Phthalates, Phosphorous, Arsenic, Antimony, or Chlorine chemical emitting components. Plus, The Little Star is made in the USA and GREENGUARD® GOLD CERTIFIED.

This Is A 2 Stage Sleep System- It Works Like This….

The Little Star has a 5″ deep mattress with a 2 stage sleep system. The side you use for infants features an extra firm layer foam which is infused with plant oils and no off gassing occurs. The other side is for your toddler which has a comfy plush, pressure reducing synthetic latex. Both sides are UL GreenGuard Gold Certified. The pad is antibacterial, regulates temperature and is extremely comfortable.

The 2 sided nature means you save money as you can use this mattress from newborn through to the toddler bed years. Another nice comfort aspect are the SafeSewn seams. This means the seams are dropped down to the mattress sides and stitched flat, making changing sheet and cleaning much easier. The cotton cover zips off to put in the washing machine

  • Fitted, Zip Off Cotton Covers: The first benefit is the zip off organic cotton cover. The Little Star Organic Crib Mattress has an organic cotton cover which is water, stain and odor resistant as well as an antimicrobial finish. It gives the most chemical free possible sleeping environment for your baby. Organic cotton is completely natural. It is grown without chemical fertilizers, synthetic pesticides or herbicides.
  • 5 Inch Deep Dual Stage Mattress: Usually, the part where organic crib mattresses lack the feature “Organic” is the cover of the mattress itself. A mattress filled with organic materials but wrapped with a toxic cover makes no sense and vice versa. Normally organic crib mattresses tend to cost more as organic materials cost more to produce. The Little Star has an extra firm layer foam infused with plant oils which is prefect for babies who front sleep or roll over. I wanted to know if Moonlight used safe glues…. here’s what Moonlight say on their site “Simalfa, an adhesive company committed to offering only environmentally friendly products and services. They have received the coveted UL GREENGUARD Sustainability Award and are UL’s GreenGuard Gold approved.”
  • Plush Synthetic Latex Foam For Toddlers: Toddlers often need a little more comfort to sleep well and its amazing how a comfy mattress can make for a happier toddler!! You can flip the mattress over from about 9 months old and only then when you are completely sure that it is safe for your baby. The synthetic latex is a plush, softer surface which is designed to be antibacterial as well breathable to reduce sweatiness, helping to regulate your babies sleeping temperature to keep them comfortable.
  • Hygiene, Comfort and Durability: The inner cover of the Little Star is designed to be cleaned with a damp sponge and warm water. You can safely use mild liquid soap if you prefer without any issues. It’s important not use any harsh cleaners, antibacterial or diaper wipes, as these may eventually break down the surface of any mattress. The cover zips off for machine washing and dry on a gentle/low cycle.
what size is a crib mattress

Best Innerspring Crib Mattress

Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II Review
The Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II is made with natural and sustainable materials. And, in case you are wondering, Colgate is a family owned and operated business and has no relationship whatsoever to the toothpaste brand!

An Innerspring Crib Mattress May Weigh More…

Remember we mentioned earlier that innerspring mattresses were possibly considered a little old-fashioned? They are still a great option and many of us grew up sleeping on an innerspring mattress. A high quality mattress will typically weigh around 30 pounds more because of the thicker gauge steel coils and extra padding. At the end of the day, there is no right or wrong option-it comes down to your personal preference and your budget.

They are a more durable option as they are made up of coils, casings, comfort foams and more whereas foam mattresses are completely different construction.

The Best Innerspring Crib Mattress Offers Even Body Weight Distribution

Good quality innerspring mattresses are more supportive of the child’s body weight as the coils evenly distributes the weight of the sleeping child. The benefit of this is better spinal alignment. The important aspect to take into account is make sure there is enough cushioning so you can’t feel any springs poking through!

The EcoSpring Is Made From Sustainable Coir Fibers…

There are a lot of things to like about the EcoSpring Ultra II. As already mentioned, the components of any crib mattress are important. Are they synthetic? Do they offgass? Are the organic components supportive? All of these things can affect your baby and for me, safety and good health is first and foremost above all else.

The EcoSpring is made from cushioning layers of coir fibre which comes from the outer husk of the coconut shell which is a sustainable fiber. The eco-friendly foam is made with sustainable plant oils and it’s both hypoallergenic and phthalate free. The fibers used means it’s naturally fire resistant-no fire retardant chemicals used at all.

The entire mattress is wrapped in a cotton damask cover which is stain resistant, waterproof and tear resistant. For an extra level of hygiene, you can always buy a waterproof crib mattress cover which is easier to wash. That way the mattress cover stays pristine and protected from leakage accidents!

What About The Innerspring Coils?

There are 150 evenly spaced coils of extra thick 13.5 gauge steel coils to evenly distribute the babies body weight. One thing to be careful of when buying innerspring crib mattresses other border rods. It’s really important these rods give strong edge support so that each of the mattress doesn’t dip down into the crib, causing tiny legs and arms to get caught.

The border rods are made from 9.0 gauge steel to give the firmest edge possible.

  • Extra firm: The Colgate EcoSpring Ultra II provides extra firmness. This baby crib mattress pad is filled with 150 high quality 13.5-gauge steel coils for even firmness- there are no soft spots. You know you have a quality mattress with a guarantee a long durable life for as long as you need it. Once your child has grown out of their crib, you can always either pass it along or use it for a dogs bed which we read with some amusement. Strong edge support with 9.0-gauge steel border rods means the mattress fits firmly against crib borders without dipping down. If you aren’t sure about innersprings, it’s worth taking some time to read crib mattress pad reviews. They’ll help you understand more.
  • Coir Fiber Inner: The coconut husk fibres are placed on each side of the springs and stop the springs poking through. You can see the layers used in the image above. The good thing about coir fibres is they are a natural fire retardant so no chemicals are used. The EcoSpring has the GREENGUARD® Gold and CertiPUR-US® certified safe for no harmful emissions seal of approval.
  • Extra Comfort With Allergen Free Environment: The natural cotton batting layers offer allergen protection.
what to look for in a baby mattress

Best Foam Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Crib Mattress Review

Let me introduce you to Sealy Corp. Sealy Corp. is a renowned bedding manufacturer with over 130 years of experience. I think they have more than enough experience to know how to make the perfect mattress for babies to adults …. since they first began in 1881. This is one of the best mattresses for infants at the mid range level of pricing so it may suit your budget very well.

Sealy Use Natures Best Materials In This Award Winning 2 Stage Mattress…

Sealy are committed to using some of nature’s best materials along with the latest cutting edge technologies in sleep comfort. They make some of the top rated baby mattresses on the market. The Sealy Soybean Foam mattress is a two-stage baby crib mattress pad to carry infants over to a toddler bed. I do like these mattresses as they offer you cost savings.

I was interested to read this is an award winning mattress as it uses renewable soya beans to manufacturer the firm, small-cell high-density foam core in this crib mattress. The soya beans are grown by American farmers and do not come from China.

Comfort is always paramount and the high-density core is padded out with cotton cushioning to provide a balanced sleeping surface.

Waterproof Crib Mattress Covers Can Be Wiped Down…

The cover isn’t removable, however it is made from waterproof fabric with a pearl embossed finish. You can clean it with a baby wipe all some warm soapy water. You don’t have to worry about leakage seeping into the seams as they are lock stitched to stop that happening. The pearl embossed finish prevents allergens from clinging to the mattress.

Over 100 Safety Tests…

Over 100 tests have been done on the quality, durability, safety and chemical content and its been certified for low chemical emissions and indoor air quality for a baby’s healthy sleeping environment.

And importantly, it’s made without phthalates, lead, mercury, formaldehyde, PBDES, TDCPP or TCEP flame retardants that non-certified foams can’t claim.

  • Soybean Oil Based Foam: The foam used in Sealy Soybean foam-core crib mattress is made from renewable soybean oil based grown by farmers in the USA.
  • Waterproof With Safety: This crib mattress is waterproof. I am overly a fan of waterproofing features as they may contain toxic materials. Sealy has achieved the GREENGUARD GOLD certified seal so we know the pearl finished cover that is free of any harmful lead and phthalates.
  • Lightweight: It is very lightweight being foam so it’s easy to move and handle.
best mattress for baby cot bed

What Kept In Mind To Choose the Best Crib Mattress

  • Foam density: The top rated foam crib mattresses for a baby are made from small cell high density foam. The denser the foam is, the better it will retain form and structure without taking on your baby’s shape as they spend so many hours sleeping. If you choose to buy a foam crib pad, make sure the foam component uses high density foam please.
  • Cover quality: Usually a crib mattress is covered with either a fabric or vinyl cover. If the mattress cover doesn’t zip off, make sure you could wipe it down with a baby wipe or warm soapy water for hygiene reasons.
  • Air circulation: Many crib mattresses offer builtin features which allow air circulation. This provides a healthier environment for your baby, stops them getting so sweaty as they sleep, helping with temperature regulation. Breathable crib mattress reviews will let you know the degree of air movement. For some parents, and rightly so, this is an important aspect.
  • Innerspring Coils: The more innerspring coils, or coil count, the better quality the crib mattress is. Some of the more expensive crib mattresses have coil counts of over 300. The gauge of the steel springs matters as well so look for 12 and above in the actual coils and 9.0 in the border rods.
  • Border rods: Border rods are a very important aspect of an innerspring crib mattress as they hold the edges in place and shape.
  • Insulation Padding: Make sure there are a few layers of insulator on top of the spring coils. The best insulator padding is usually made with from cotton, wool, coir fiber. Another pad named ‘rag’ is also available in the market wrapping spring crib mattresses.
  • Certifications: Go for the best! Look for these certifications- Greenguard Gold Certified, CertiPUR-US Certified foam or GOTS certified organic

Didn’t Quite Get There?

Well, that’s all for the moment. The choices above will get you inspired and we know you will find exactly the right brand and model for your needs and budget for buying the best crib mattress for a baby. You can also visit here for a detailed crib mattress buying guide. As you browse, do make the time to read the best crib mattress pad reviews. They give you a detailed rundown and user experience, especially on Amazon. If you are looking for mattresses which are specifically breathable, make sure you google “breathable crib mattress reviews” to find out which are the most suitable designs.

May your child be in good health. Happy parenting!!

If you managed to fit into the baby crib somehow, You will feel comfortable too. ha ha ha.